Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Geology of the National Parks in Pictures - Ellis Island, Part of the Statue of Liberty National Monument

My next post about the Geology of the National Parks Through Pictures is from the second half of the Statue of Liberty National Monument. The park is essentially two main parts, the first is the Statue of Liberty, and the second is Ellis Island. And since they are really their own entities, I will treat them separately. 


You can find more Geology of the National Parks Through Pictures as well as my Geological State Symbols Across America series at my website Dinojim.com.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ellis Island

Part of the Statue of Liberty National Monument


Since Ellis Island is a part of the Statue of Liberty National Monument, I technically already have an entrance photo shot. However, this will make due for this part of the park, since (if you squint), you can see a sign for the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration in the lower right hand corner of the photo. 

View of Ellis Island from the Statue of Liberty

Although the two islands are really close to each other, you can clearly see Ellis Island from Liberty Island in the photo above, the bedrock geology is wildly different. And that is because there is a major fault line that runs through the middle of Ellis Island. 

Bedrock Geology Map of Liberty and Ellis Islands (Volkert, 2016).

While Liberty Island sits entirely to the right of the Cameron's Line fault (dashed line with black triangles in the map above), Ellis Island sits right on top of it. Cameron's Line is a thrust fault that separates land that was deposited as part of North America, and would be considered native, with land that had been formed elsewhere and was then accreted on to North America later, and would be considered foreign. Much of the land that is New England was glommed on to North America as the neighboring Iapetus Ocean, was closing. The Iapetus Ocean was essentially the ancestral Atlantic Ocean before the formation of Pangea. 

Illustration of Cameron's Line. Image courtesy of Infographics, Maps, Music and More

The rocks on right hand (eastern) side of Cameron's Line are the Middle Cambrian to Middle Ordovician age (~510 to 460 million years old) Hartland Formation (identified as OCh on the map above). These are the same rocks that make up the bedrock of Liberty Island. The Hartland Formation is one of the two primary metamorphic rocks that make up the basement rocks of NYC. It underlies most of the western part and southern half of Manhattan and the eastern Bronx, as well as the islands within the New York Bay and into parts of New Jersey. 

Ellis Island as seen entering the inlet where the ferry docks. 

While Liberty Island is entirely underlain by the Hartland Formation, Ellis Island is only approximately  half underlain but it. The Hartland Formation was originally a sedimentary rock that was deposited in the deep ocean, in an area surrounded by volcanoes. These volcanoes would occasionally introduce volcanic sediment into the basin mixed with other sources of sediment that added sand and clay. These sediments were then metamorphosed and glued onto the edge of North America when North America ran into some off shore volcanic islands, adding those volcanic islands to the bulk of North America. This collision initiated the formation of the Appalachian Mountains, a period of time known as the Taconic Orogeny. 

Part of the island seen across the inlet from the ferry dock. This is identified as the Main Hospital Building. The Statue of Liberty can be seen in the distance.

Through the middle of Ellis Island (as seen on the geological map above) is another transported rock (termed allochthonous, meaning not native rocks). This rock is the Upper Cambrian to Lower Ordovician age Serpentinite (identified as OCs on the map). This is a metamorphosed deep marine rock, much like the neighboring Hartland Formation. What differentiates the two formations is that the Serpentinite, which is a type of rock not a formation name, is metamorphosed basalt from the ocean floor, while the Hartland Formation is made up of metamorphosed sediments that laid on top of this basalt.   

Ferry building at the end of the ferry inlet.

The third rock that forms the basement of Ellis Island, and the one underlying the western most part of the island, is the Middle Ordovician age (454 million years ago) Walloomsac Formation (identified as Ow on the geological map above). The Walloomsac Formation is to the "left" of the Cameron's Line Thrust Fault, meaning that it was not added on later, like the other two formations, but was initially deposited as part of North America. The geological term for this is an autochthonous deposit (meaning native to North America, unlike the allochthonous Hartland Formation). While the Walloomsac Formation is currently a metamorphic graphite-rich schist with some marble mixed in, it was originally deposited as a series of limestone, mudstone, and sandstone layers all interbedded with each other on the continental shelf edge. These layers then underwent metamorphism as the Iapetus Ocean was closing up and the Taconic Mountains were being formed. During and after the mountain building/metamorphism, the Hartland Formation was pushed up and over on top of parts of the Walloomsac formation. Cameron's Line is the thrust fault/division that marks the boundary between where the edge of North America originally lay and where the outside rocks were thrust upon the North American rocks. 
 
Surficial Geology Map of Liberty and Ellis Islands (Stanford, 1995)

Like Liberty Island, there is also overlying sediment. However, unlike Liberty Island, Ellis Island has some more added to it in the modern age. Above is the Surficial Geology map of the area surrounding Ellis and Liberty Islands. If we zoom in on Ellis Island it will be easier to see:

Close up of Ellis Island on the Surficial Geology Map (Stanford, 1995)

You can see that the northeastern half of the island, where the Ellis Island National Museum of Immigration, and the only place most visitors are allowed to go, is located, is underlain by the deposit identified with a Qbn. This is the same formation as Liberty Island and represents Deltaic Deposits. These are sediments that are deposited at the end of a river system, which is a mixture of rocks from further up river. These likely are related to being located at the headwaters of the Hudson and East Rivers. 


You can see on the map above and the model below, the original shape of Ellis Island, which is where those deltaic deposits were laid. However, there are more deposits identified on the Surficial Geology map and these are listed as af/Qm. This stands for artificial fill/estuarine and salt marsh deposits. The estuarine and salt marsh deposits were likely just the river bed deposits laid down from normal river processes, however where did this artificial fill come from?


It turns out, that while constructing the New York City subways, the rocks that were excavated for the subway tunnels back in the early 1900's were partially used to expand Ellis Island by several acres. The original island was just ~3 acres, however the addition of debris from the subway excavations eventually expanded the island to nearly 28 acres. The Interborough Rapid Transit Subway, or IRT, was the first subway excavated in NYC, opening in 1904. 

First subway line map. Image courtesy of the Tenement Museum. 

The original 1904 subway line was 9.1 miles long and produced over a million cubic yards of rocks and soil. The material produced was a mixture of soil, mostly glacial debris that covered the bedrock, and the Manhattan Schist, which forms the bedrock for the majority of Manhattan. Ellis Island was then expanded with the materials from the BMT subway lines in Brooklyn, which were constructed in 1911, and Ellis Island eventually reached its final size by 1934. 

A piece of Manhattan Schist in Hamilton Heights. Image courtesy of New York City Walk. 

The Manhattan Schist is another Ordovician Age, 450 million years old, metamorphic rock, similar to the Hartland Formation. The Manhattan Schist formed from sandstone and mudstone sediments that were originally deposited in the deep marine Iapetus Ocean. These sediments were metamorphosed during the shrinking of the Iapetus Ocean as the off-shore volcanic islands were being welded onto North America. While formed similarly to the Hartland Formation, it is thought that the depositional environment for the Manhattan Schist sediments was further offshore and in deeper water. 


Side note: Ellis Island was originally entirely within the domain of New York State, based on a 1834 compact between the states that set the boundary between the states as the middle of the river but gave jurisdiction of the islands in the river to New York. However the expansion of the island created new land on the New Jersey side of the river, and therefore New Jersey claimed the portions of the island that were expanded. New York fought that assertion, since it was constructed of debris from the New York City subway lines. This battle was eventually lost by NY and the island has since been split between NY and NJ, with NY taking ownership of any part of the island that originally existed (the 3 acres) and NJ owning the remaining ~24 acres that surround the original island. 

References

Wednesday, November 11, 2026

Geology in Pop Culture - Volcanoes Part 3: The Stradivarius Violin

  

Volcanos Part 3: The Stradivarius Violin

(AKA the influence of volcanic eruptions)


Volcanic eruptions have had many pop-culture influences over the years including influencing art, literature, and even music. We are going to look at three notable instances. These include Mary Shelley's Frankenstein published in 1818, Edvard Munch's painting The Scream from 1893, and Antonio Stradivari violins of the 1600's and 1700's.  

Antonio Stradivari Violins (1600's and 1700's)

Born in 1644, it is estimated that Antonio Stradivari began making notable quality violins by the age of 16. A naturally skilled luthier, someone who makes stringed instruments, Stradivari is credited with the creation of the modern violin form including adjustments to the bridge, deepening the color, and adjusting some of the proportions.  

Stradivarius violin. Image courtesy of NPR. 

Although he began crafting violins as a young age, likely under a mentor, it wasn't until 1700 that Stradivari hit his stride, with the period from 1700 through 1725 considered as the Golden Period of Stradivarius creations. But what makes Stradivarius violins so special? Although they are extremely well crafted, being perfectly symmetrical and flawless, that is not the primary reason they are sought out by collectors. Most collectors agree that the sound from a Stradivarius violin is superior to other violins (although scientific studies have questioned this). It is claimed that a Stradivarius violin has a crisper, cleaner, and richer tone, especially when compared to his contemporaries. 


But why does it sound differently from other violins? There have been many theories from the type of varnish used, the chemicals used to treat the wood, the violin shape, and/or the structure of the violin, but science may have solved this one too (or at least it is still under debate). One of the leading theories though is related to volcanoes. 

Density comparison of modern violins to classical violins (Cremonese) such as Stradivari. Image courtesy of Stoel and Borman, 2008.

It turns out that the wood used by luthiers from Cremona, Italy, which included Stradivari, was naturally much denser than most wood used to make violins, especially modern day instruments. And this increased density is because they have a much closer, more even, growth ring density. As trees grow, there are two components to the wood they produce. It is common knowledge that a tree produces a ring for each year it is alive. What is considered the growth ring is actually slowed down growth during late summer, fall months when the tree is not able to grow as fast and smaller wood cells are produced. Therefore the wood in these rings is denser. During warmer months, trees are able to grow faster and therefore produce lighter, spongier wood in between each of the winter rings. The Norway Spruce and maples trees used by Stradivari were more dense because they had closer spaced tree rings than is normally common. 


Growth rings seen on a Stradivari violin. Image courtesy of the NY Times. 


These trees grew up during a period of time known as the Little Ice Age. While the Little Ice Age lasted from the 1300's through the mid 1800's, there was a period of time known as the Maunder Minimum (1645 through 1715), which are the coldest parts of the Little Ice Age, with a European drop in average temperatures from 1 to 2 °C (1.8 to 3.6 °F). The Maunder Minimum is named after Edward Walter Maunder, who discovered the decreased number of sunspots during this period and later scientists correlated it with the colder stretch of time. While many scientists agree that reduced sunspot activity can reduce solar energy and therefore reduce global temperatures, there were also other agencies at work during the Little Ice Age to decrease global temperatures.

Sunspot activity over the last 400 years. Image courtesy of Britannica.

Between 1630-1850 there were 16 major volcanic eruptions of a VEI 5 or greater that scientists estimate had at least a 40% impact on global cooling. While 16 is a lot of major eruptions, there were at least 3 VEI 6 size eruptions from 1640 through 1700, the exact time frame when the trees that Stradivari used would have been growing. These eruptions included Komagatake Volcano in Japan that erupted in 1640, Long Island in New Guinea that erupted in 1660, and Usu Volcano in Japan that erupted in 1663.  

It is estimated that the total volume of eruptive tephra from the 1640 eruption of Komagatake Volcano is 3.5 cubic km with 1 to 2 meters of ash fall within the surrounding countryside. The 1660 eruption of Long Island is estimated to have a total volume of 11 cubic kilometers of volcanic tephra. And during the 1663 eruption of Usu Volcano, it is estimated that 2.5 cubic km of tephra was erupted. All of these eruptions combines introduced significant amounts of not only ash, but volcanic gases as well, which block solar radiation and help push global temperatures down during the duration of the Little Ice Age, especially the Maunder Minimum.  

And while reduced global temperatures may have a minimal to slightly noticeable impact on tropical and even temperate regions, the source for Stradivari's violins was the much higher elevations of the Italian Alps. It is thought that Stradivari sources his trees from the Val di Fiemme near Trentino, Italy, with elevations in this region ranging from 2,640 feet above sea level on the valley floor to almost 10,000 feet above sea level at the peaks of the mountains. So, not only were these trees already growing in a high altitude, volcanic activity likely pushed global temperatures colder, resulting in stunted tree growth and denser trees, which in essence produced the dulcet tones of a Stradivarius violin. 

References

Monday, November 02, 2026

Geology of the National Parks in Pictures - Statue of Liberty National Monument

My next post about the Geology of the National Parks Through Pictures is from the first half of the Statue of Liberty National Monument. The park is essentially two main parts, the first is the Statue of Liberty, and the second is Ellis Island. And since they are really their own entities, I will treat them separately. 


You can find more Geology of the National Parks Through Pictures as well as my Geological State Symbols Across America series at my website Dinojim.com.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Statue of Liberty National Monument


Obligatory entrance sign


The Statue of Liberty sits on Liberty Island within the Upper New York Bay near the confluence of the Hudson River and the East River. There are actually numerous geological features for the Statue of Liberty as well as Liberty Island itself. Starting from the ground up, let us look Liberty Island itself.

Bedrock Geology Map of Liberty and Ellis Islands (Volkert, 2016).

The bedrock of Liberty Island is made up entirely of what is labeled as OCh on the Geological Map above. This is the Middle Cambrian to Middle Ordovician age (~510 to 460 million years old) Hartland Formation (per the map key). The Hartland Formation is one of the two primary metamorphic rocks that make up the basement rocks of NYC. It underlies most of the western part and southern half of Manhattan and the eastern Bronx, as well as the islands within the New York Bay and into parts of New Jersey. 


The Hartland Formation was originally a sedimentary rock that was deposited in the deep ocean, in an area surrounded by volcanoes. These volcanoes would occasionally introduce volcanic sediment into the basin mixed with other sources of sediment that added sand and clay. These sediments were then metamorphosed when North America ran into some off shore volcanic islands. This collision initiated the formation of the Appalachian Mountains, a period of time known as the Taconic Orogeny. 

Surficial Geology Map of Liberty and Ellis Islands (Stanford, 1995)

On top of the bedrock sits what is known as surficial deposits. Many areas of New York, like notably Long Island, have large amounts of glacial debris sitting on top of the bedrock. Liberty Island, however, does not appear to have glacial debris. On the Surficial Geology map above, the surficial deposits are  labeled as Qbn, which represents Deltaic Deposits. These are sediments that are deposited at the end of a river system, which is a mixture of rocks from further up river. These likely are related to being located at the headwaters of the Hudson and East Rivers. 


Moving upwards from Liberty Island, we can take a look at the Statue of Liberty herself, or more specifically, the pedestal for the statues. The pedestal for the statue is largely made up of concrete, as it would need to support the weight of the statue. However, there is a granitic facade meant to "pretty up" the statue. 


When you look downwards on the statue though, you can see that the lower base is arrayed in a star shape. This is because this was a pre-existing structure already on Liberty Island, a military fort known as Fort Wood. Most of the fort was converted and filled with concrete in order to support the statue. You can see remnants of the forts in various places across the lower foundation.


After the foundation was constructed within the fort, and then built up to form the pedestal for the statue, the concrete surface was then adorned with this lovely pink granite. The pink granite stones were purchased from Beattie Quarry (also known as the Leete Island Quarry) in Guilford, Connecticut, which was owned and operated by Scottish immigrant John Beattie. Stones from this quarry were used on other monuments and buildings such as Grant's Tomb (another National Park), the George Washington Bridge in New York City, the Battle Monument at West Point, and the museum buildings of the Smithsonian Institution in DC.


The name of this granite goes by a few names including the Leete Island Granite, Stony Creek Granite, and Stony Creek Gneiss, but geologically it seems that Stony Creek Granite is the primary name. The area where this granite is found in Connecticut has several different types of granite deposits that all flow into one another. These are dependent on the source rock and the degree of metamorphism which altered some of the granites into the metamorphic rock gneiss. The Stony Creek Granite can be described as a pink granite with medium to very coarsely grained, comprised of the minerals oligoclase, K-feldspar, and quartz with minor biotite, magnetite, garnet, and muscovite. The Stony Creek Granite formed roughly 600 million years ago, during the Proterozoic during another mountain building event known as the Avalonian Orogeny. The Avalonian Orogeny formed the Avalon Platform of Newfoundland, however effects of that mountain building event extended down into New England. During this time there was lots of magma that rose up towards the surface and cooled slowly underneath the ground to form the core granitic bodies. Over time these granites were partially metamorphosed to create the patches of gneisses. 


Moving our way upwards, we get to the Statue of Liberty herself, focusing on the geology of her copper coating. The Statue of Liberty contains 176,000 pounds of copper that is hammered out to a thickness of 3/32 of an inch, which is the thickness of 2 copper pennies placed together. It is generally thought that the source of the copper is from the copper mines of Visnes at Karmoy, a small rocky island near Stavanger in Norway. These mines were owned by France at the time of the statue's construction, however that alone wasn't evidence enough to link the two. That is when a metallurgical analysis of the copper by Bell Labs confirmed that the impurities within the Statue of Liberty's copper matched those in the Visnes mines, indicating a likely match. 

Looking up the stairs towards the crown, off limits when we were there. 

The rock unit the copper came from is known as the Karmøy ophiolite, an Early Ordovician (~480 million years old) rock that formed as part of the sub-floor of the ocean. An ophiolite is a geological term for part of the oceanic crust that is brought up onto land. Part of this ophiolite complex contains what is known as the Visnes massive Fc-Cu-Zn sulfide deposit, where the copper used in the Statue of Liberty was found. This copper deposit was formed when basaltic rocks in the sub-sea floor were altered by the presence of magma-influenced hydrothermal fluids. This is the way a lot of copper deposits are formed, when you have a magma body heating up the ground waters and enriching them with metallic and other elements common in magmatic bodies but not common in sedimentary environments. 


The final geological process is more of a chemical process, and that is the conversion of the copper colored copper to the green that we know the Statue of Liberty to be. While this is mostly a chemistry aspect, we can address it here as well. The answer is oxidation, also known as rust, however in copper the process is also known as patination. The oxidation process where iron is turned red by the addition of oxygen to form rust is a similar process for copper. The copper molecules combine with the oxygen to form a green patina crust to the copper plating. When originally constructed, the statue was actually the copper color of a new penny.  

References

Monday, October 26, 2026

Geology in Pop Culture - Volcanoes Part 2: The Scream

 

Volcanos Part 1: The Scream 

(AKA the influence of volcanic eruptions)


Volcanic eruptions have had many pop-culture influences over the years including influencing art, literature, and even music. We are going to look at three notable instances. These include Mary Shelley's Frankenstein published in 1818, Edvard Munch's painting The Scream from 1893, and Antonio Stradivari violins of the 1600's and 1700's.  

Edvard Munch's The Scream (1893)

 Edvard Munch, The Scream, 1893, Nasjonalmuseet, Oslo, Norway

Edvard Munch was a Norwegian artist, living in Norway at the time. In his diary entry of January 22, 1892, Munch had described his inspiration for The Scream:
One evening I was walking along a path, the city was on one side and the fjord below. I felt tired and ill. I stopped and looked out over the fjord—the sun was setting, and the clouds turning blood red. I sensed a scream passing through nature; it seemed to me that I heard the scream. I painted this picture, painted the clouds as actual blood. The color shrieked. This became The Scream.
There is also a poem that he had written from 1895 with much the same vibe (Daily Art Magazine):
I was walking along the road with two friends – the sun was setting – suddenly the sky turned blood red – I paused, feeling exhausted, and leaned on the fence – there was blood and tongues of fire above the blue-black fjord and the city – my friends walked on, and I stood there trembling with anxiety – and I sensed an infinite scream passing through nature.
There is no set time when this happened though, except that it must have been before the 1892 journal entry. It has been postulated (Olson et al., 2004) that the cause of this "blood red" sunset was from the eruption of the volcano Krakatoa in Indonesia on August 27th, 1883. 

And while the eruption of Krakatoa was literally half a world away, there are other instances where the eruption impacted sunsets across the globe. There is a report in Pennsylvania from the Hanover Spectator from December 19th of 1883 where it is reported:
Residents “… witnessed a most beautiful and startling phenomenon … the sky … was fairly aglow with crimson and golden fires.”
Mount Krakatoa. Image courtesy of the Global Volcanism Project. 

Krakatoa (or Mount Krakatoa) is a stratovolcano located within the Pacific Ring of Fire and produced one of the largest eruptions in recorded history. 

During the eruption, ash was sent 50 miles into the atmosphere covering 300,000 square miles. The final eruption produced a shockwave that was heard by 10% of the Earth's surface and ejected as much as 5 cubic miles of rock fragments into the air, causing the island to collapse down into its 3.8 mile wide caldera. In addition, pyroclastic flows were produced, clouds of hot dust and ash of more than 300 degrees Celsius traveling at over 100 kph, wiping out everything for miles around the volcano. And the most devastation was produced by the series of tsunamis that smashed into 165 coastal villages in the surrounding islands of Java and Sumatra, extending to the Arabian peninsula, killing 36,000 people. The ash eventually circled the globe dropping the global temperature by a full degree Celsius the year following the eruption. It took 5 years for the Earth's temperature to revert to normal. 

It seems like based on Munch's personal accounts of the blood red sunset and the cause of that sunset, that it was indeed possible that the eruption was the impetus for the creation of The Scream.


Tuesday, October 13, 2026

Geology in Pop Culture - Volcanoes Part 1: Frankenstein

Volcanos Part 1: Frankenstein 

(AKA the influence of volcanic eruptions)


Volcanic eruptions have had many pop-culture influences over the years including influencing art, literature, and even music. We are going to look at three notable instances. These include Mary Shelley's Frankenstein published in 1818, Edvard Munch's painting The Scream from 1893, and Antonio Stradivari violins of the 1600's and 1700's. 

Mary Shelley's Frankenstein or the Modern Prometheus (1818)


On April 5th of 1815, the Indonesian volcano, Mount Tambora began to erupt. While the eruption was huge on any scale, killing an estimated 10,000 people in proximity to the mountain, and many more beyond, the amount of material that was erupted managed to encircle the globe, blocked out the sun, and created the "year without a summer" in 1816. 

Location of Mount Tambora in Indonesia. Image courtesy of the Global Volcanism Program. 

Mount Tambora is a stratovolcano located on Sumbawa Island within Indonesia. The April eruption, which ended up lasting for months, produced pyroclastic flows that reached the seas on all sides of the peninsula. The total amount of material erupted eventually exceeded 150 cubic km of tephra (gasses, dust, and rocks that make up the volcanic material). On the volcano itself, after the eruption the top of the volcano collapsed into a caldera 6 km wide and 1250 meters deep. 

The Volcanic Explosivity Index (VEI) scale. Image courtesy of the USGS.

Volcanic eruptions are ranked in size by a VEI scale, "Volcanic Explosivity Index", with this eruption ranking a 7, the largest volcanic eruption in recorded history. While there is evidence of larger eruptions in the geological record, there are none that have been witnessed in the last few thousand years. This eruption was so loud, that it was heard over 1200 miles (1930 km) away. 

Map of temperature anomalies in Celsius across Europe during the summer of 1816 as compared to 1971-2000 climate normals. Image courtesy of UCAR Center for Science Education. 

The eruption was so large that it was able to inject a cloud the size of Australia of aerosolized volcanic debris into the atmosphere, blocking solar radiation and absorbing heat, producing a drop in global temperatures from 2 to 7 degrees F. This caused snow falls in summer and frosts that killed off crops, leading to an Irish famine, and locked people indoors for months. On July 4th, 1816, John Quincy Adams laments that he was confined to his house in London all day due to freezing rain showers and thunder. 

Tambora: The Eruption that Changed the World

Gillen D'Arcy Wood, in his book Tambora: The Eruption that Changed the World, laid out how this eruption influenced events that extend far into the 20th century. One such instance is that because of the terrible weather during the summer of 1816, Mary Shelley was locked indoors at the villa of Lord Byron on Lake Geneva, Switzerland. With her, was her husband, Percy Shelley and Lord Byron. Because of the lack of things to do, and the gloomy atmosphere outside, Lord Byron proposed a contest. Who could write the scariest ghost story. At the end of the contest, Mary, only 18 at the time, had constructed what is considered to be one of the greatest works of Gothic horror. And much to the surprise of no one, didn't win the competition, with Byron giving the victory to Percy, since Mary's work was considered "too philosophical".  

References

Wood, Gillen D’Arcy. Tambora: the eruption that changed the world. Princeton University Press, 2026.
Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein; or, The Modern Prometheus. Lackington, Hughes, Harding, Mavor, & Jones, 1818